Faith-Based Media Blog | Family Theater Productions

'Ebenezer': Johnny Depp in a Dickens Classic That Has Goth ... and God

Written by Kate O'Hare | Nov 20, 2026, 1:13:44 AM

November is the month that Catholics begin by thinking of departed souls, Purgatory, and the Four Last Things: Death, Judgment, Heaven, and Hell. So, it's a perfect time for Ebenezer, a new feature-film version of Charles Dickens' 1843 novella A Christmas Carol. In Prose. Being a Ghost Story of Christmas.

Yes, another one.

Ebenezer Scrooge ... Again?

Having landed in theaters on Nov. 13 — and earned, so far, almost $47M worldwide — Ebenezer comes from director Ti West, best known for horror films, and writer Nathaniel Halpern, whose credits are mostly from TV (Tales From the Loop, Legion, Resurrection).

It's a U.S./UK co-production, shot in the U.K. and Dublin, and released by Paramount Pictures in the U.S.

And before you say "Another version of A Christmas Carol? (there are likely 200, not counting TV episodes), let me explain that this work is in the public domain, so you don't have to pay royalties to adapt it -- just like, to name a few, other works by Dickens, Jane Austen, Sherlock Holmes stories, and Shakespeare.

It will never end.

That being said, Dickens' original took place in the grimier and more squalid areas of London, in the heart of the Victorian era. It reflected the author's own backstory (see the film The Man Who Invented Christmas for a fanciful version of that), and the grinding poverty he saw all around him.

In many unfortunate ways, Dickens' London resembles several of our own cities, but the exact circumstances and responses are different. However, the truths about human nature in the story are as relevant today as ever.

So, in each iteration and for each generation, the emphasis and focus shift, and very different actors — from Alistair Sim to Mr. Magoo to Mickey Mouse to Kermit to Patrick Stewart to George C. Scott — step into the main role.

What Happens in Ebenezer? (After All, Not Every Person Now Alive Knows the Story)

Johnny Depp plays mean-spirited businessman Ebenezer Scrooge, complete with muttonchops, a pointed nose, and a snarlingly bad attitude. Ian McKellan plays his business partner, Jacob Marley (and, subsequently, Marley's slack-jawed ghost); Rupert Grint is their long-suffering clerk Bob Cratchit; and Sam Claflin and Daisy Ridley are Scrooge's kind nephew Fred and wife, respectively.

In the wake of Marley's demise on an earlier Christmas Eve, miserable miser Ebenezer — who has also lost the two women who mattered most to him in life — is especially nasty to all around him as Christmas approaches. He deems the holiday to be a humbug, British slang for a deception, hoax, or just plan nonsense.

Out of friendship and in atonement for his own missed opportunities in life, the suffering ghost of Marley offers Scrooge the unwelcome prospect of being haunted by three spirits on Christmas Eve. It's framed as Ebenezer's last chance to redeem himself in the eyes of the world (and God).

Against his will, Ebenezer is spun through his past, present, and future ... and it ain't pretty in any direction.

If Ebenezer doesn't mend his ways by Christmas Day, it could be curtains (or, no curtains, as it were), for the cranky old man.

So, What's Special About Ebenezer?

Director West brings a distinctly Gothic — and even Goth — sensibility to the story and a good dose of dark humor. While hardly in the splatterfest-horror category, there are disturbing, even gruesome, images, and jump scares.

Murders of crows lurk about; wailing, zombie-like spirits wander the streets (and try to get in); and mist swirls among gravestones.

The Ghost of Christmas Past (Andrea Riseborough) is far more wraithlike than usually portrayed; and the Ghost of Christmas Present (Tramell Tillman), who normally starts out jolly before taking a turn, just takes the turn right away and stays there.

Interestingly, the Christ in Christmas is more present here than I've ever seen in a version of this tale. The Gothic sensibility is deeply interwoven with Catholic imagery, and its use here seems to give permission for the appearance of churches, the preaching of the actual Gospel of Christmas, and a good dose of memento mori.

One segment features beautiful, even haunting, if you will, renditions of Silent Night, a German hymn which would have been only 25 years old at the time of the novella's publication.

The themes of faith, mercy, grace, penance, repentance, and forgiveness are very much to the fore, and some parts of the story often given short shrift (even by Dickens) are fleshed out.

But, Is Ebenezer Faithful to Dickens?

More or less, but that's true of all adaptations (check out the book sometime, it's a ripping good read and surprisingly funny).

Many of Dickens' signature lines are present, but I did miss some that weren't there. Themes more hinted at in earlier versions are explicity stated here, but that may be a nod to a younger audience less inherently familiar with the story's underlying theology and philosophy.

The script follows the general outline of the story, with variations and a slightly different ending (No, don't fear for Tiny Tim. They didn't go that far afield).

Also, in what has become a cliché of modern historical costume drama, London appears to be vastly more diverse than it actually was at the time, especially in the background casting. One day, movies from this era will be able to be indentified by that alone.

Ebenezer retains all the moral lessons in A Christmas Carol, just with a bit of a horror twist.

Is Ebenezer Suitable for Families?

The film is rated PG-13 and earns it. There's no overt violence, nudity or bad language, but it's more a walk through the graveyard than a stroll in the park. Middle-schoolers and up may be ready for a spook or two, but littles should probably stay home and watch the Muppet version instead.

Ebenezer suffers from occasional on-the-nose dialogue and excessive exposition, but ultimately, it's an entertaining, faith-infused (if not perfectly faithful) version of a tale that, spirit-like, rises again for each new audience.

 

Image: Paramount

Kate O’Hare, a longtime entertainment journalist, is Social Media Content Manager and Blog Editor at Family Theater Productions. 

More Like This:

'I Play Rocky': An Underdog's Leap of Faith Onto a Movie Screen

'Sense and Sensibility': Not Exactly Austen but Charming

From 'The Gilded Age' to Austen: The Best Historical Costume Dramas

'Hamnet': Film Looks at Grief and the Ghost in Shakespeare's 'Hamlet'

 Keep up with Family Theater Productions our website, X, Instagram and YouTube.